Open Letter
By FREDRIC KOEPPEL
November 02, 1999
Today is merlot blowout day. The categories are Cheap ($12
and under), Moderate (up to $19), Expensive ($19-$35) and
Really Expensive (way up there). Within the sections, the
progress is more or less from Avoid to Exceptional.
CHEAP
Though endowed with a bouquet of dried thyme, spicy oak
and wild cherry and raspberry, the barky, weedy character
of the disappointing Rivefort de France Merlot 1996 swamps
whatever flavors there might be. Avoid. About $6.
The Beaulieu Vineyards Coastal Merlot 1997, California is
simple, direct and a bit rough around the edges. Good only.
About $11.
Slightly better is the Carramar Estate Merlot 1998, South
Eastern Australia, which features intense black cherry and
raspberry fruit touched with coffee and chocolate and pleasant
density; if only the finish weren't so severe. Good plus.
About $10.
Better is Georges Duboeuf's Merlot 1998, Vin de Pays d'Oc,
a rustic wine whose bright, fresh, floral qualities and tasty
plum-cassis flavors shadowed with oak make for a nice quaff.
Very good-. About $7.
Also marked Very good are La Playa Reserve Merlot 1996,
Maipo Valley, Chile, a simple but attactively polished, floral
and spicy wine that devolves to a fairly astringent finish,
about $10, and the Forest Glen Merlot 1997, California, whose
bright bouquet of smoke and herbs, chocolate and orange zest,
black cherry and raspberry belies its essentially one-dimensional
flavors and texture. About $11.
Several degrees more integrated is the Bolla Merlot Piave
delle Venezia 1997, whose beguiling bouquet of dried herbs,
coffee, cedar and floral touches accented with orange rind
leads to surprising substance, vitality and intensity in the
mouth. Very good and marked as the Pick of the Week at about
$8.
Its cousin, the Bolla Colforte Merlot 1997 is discouragingly
dominated by oak and tannin and underbrushy, foresty qualities.
I'm not optimistic. About $12.
MODERATE
There's not much to say about the Jekel Merlot 1997, Monterey,
a cautiously made "me-too" merlot with the requisite
qualities but no discernible character. Good plus. About $15.
Almost gaudy with lavender and violets and heady black cherry-cassis
scents, the lovely Bayliss & Fortune Merlot 1997, Monterey,
features a succulent, dusty texture bolstering smoky plummy-jammy
flavors with just enough oak for structure. Very good. About
$14.
I don't usually think of R. H. Phillips as a noted merlot
producer, but the winery's Toasted Head Merlot 1997, Dunnigan
Hills, is a winsome little sweetheart of a wine, all velvet
and lavender and licorice, bitter chocolate and tar, orange
zest and black cherry and just enough oak and tannin to keep
it honest. Yum. Very good. About $15.
The Pellegrini Cloverdale Ranch Merlot 1997, Alexander Valley,
offers minerals, mint, exotic spice, tea, dried herbs and
ripe cassis-raspberry in the nose; flavors are well-developed
but dominated by tannin. Very good. About $16.
"Lovely" is the word for the smooth and supple
Clos Du Bois Merlot 1997, Sonoma County, a wine bursting with
notes of violets and tar, cassis and black cherry smoke and
spicy oak; though it has sufficient structure, it drinks almost
too easily. Very good. About $17.
"Wonderfully fruity" was my first note on the
Seven Peaks Merlot 1997, Central Coast, a wine whose bouquet
of minerals, vanilla, dried herbs and oaken spice and whose
polished tannic structure are shot through with luscious blueberry,
cassis and plums scents and flavors, tar and bittersweet chocolate.
Very good plus. About $16.
EXPENSIVE
Cool as ink and minerals, the Canoe Ridge Merlot 1997, Columbia
Valley, Washington, offers a ripe, intense though standard
bouquet; it's pretty tasty, in the correct ways, but lacks
vitality and vibrancy. Very good-. About $19.
Generally, I like red wines from Dry
Creek Vineyards, but the Dry Creek Merlot 1997, Sonoma
County, seems so carefully crafted that it has no personality;
its reticence feels intended to last a lifetime. Very good.
About $19.50.
The Sterling Winery Lake Vineyard Merlot 1996, Napa-Carneros,
is all structure from the inside out and needs three or four
years. Very good. About $35.
Though the astringency of the finish leaves a question mark,
the Clos Pegase Merlot 1996, Napa-Carneros, offers one of
the ripest, smokiest, most intensely vanilla-and-licorice-laced
bouquets of all these wines; in the mouth its remarkable density
seems imbued with permanent underbrush and forest elements,
Give it two or three years. Very good plus. About $23.
It could use more complexity, but the Robert Pecota Steven
Andre Vineyard merlot 1997, Napa Valley, is as lovely and
seductive as merlot gets; its potpourri-licorice-plum-cassis
fragrance balloons from the glass, while a polished grainy
texture cushions dust, minerals and luscious black cherry-raspberry
flavors. Very good plus. About $30.
What a nose on the Sterling Merlot 1997, Napa Valley! A
tremendous bouquet of smoke, minerals, bright berries and
spicy oak is followed by a huge mouthful of polished, chewy
oak and tannin, plum dust and violets, intense black cherry
and cassis flavors and a rather austere finish. Delicious
but age-worthy. Excellent. About $20.
Wonderfully clean and harmonious, the Swanson Merlot 1997,
Napa Valley, is sweetly ripe and winsome yet deeply endowed
with intense black cherry and cassis fruit bolstered by a
firm, fleshy texture and minerals that go down like liquid
velvet. Excellent. About $24.
The Frog's Leap Merlot 1997, Napa Valley, manages to be
sweetly ripe and harmonious despite its intensity and concentration
and the seeming durability of its structure; as on a customized
car, however, the detailing is perfect. Excellent. About $27.
Beringer's Alluvium 1996, Knights Valley (75 percent merlot,
the rest cabernet sauvignon and cabernet franc), displays
a core of smoke, dried flowers and exotic spice so intense
that it's startling; ripe and concentrated blueberry, plum
and black cherry flavors gain substance from dense, chewy,
minerally oak and polished tannin. Excellent. About $30.
REALLY EXPENSIVE
Between the poles of massive polished oak and grainy tannins,
on the one hand, and scintillating vanilla, lavender, licorice,
minerals and ripe plum-cassis-black cherry flavors on the
other, the Beringer Bancroft Ranch Merlot 1997, Howell Mountain,
Napa Valley, defines what merlot ought to be in California;
you could tap dance on the finish. Great now, it could age
three to six years. Exceptional. About $75.
>> How about Merlot and Chocolate for a gift or simply
for yourself? What a decadent combo. Click
here to find out more..
|